← Back to blog

By Josh Lu

Should Coaches Read Their Athletes' Journals?

You know your athletes keep notes on their training, or you want them to. Their reflections would tell you so much: what they're struggling with, what clicked, how they're really feeling. So the question comes up naturally. Should coaches read athlete journals, and if so, how much should they see?

Why "just read them" backfires

The common instinct is to require journals and collect them. It seems efficient. You'd get a direct line into each athlete's head.

The problem is what happens to the writing once athletes know you'll read every word. Reflections get shorter and safer. Athletes write what sounds coachable instead of what's true. The athlete who's frustrated with a teammate, worried about playing time, or questioning whether they even like the sport anymore stops writing those thoughts down. You end up reading a performance of reflection, and the athlete loses the private space where real self-awareness gets built.

Journals are most valuable when they're honest. Honesty depends on the writer knowing who the audience is and trusting it, which is one of the foundations of a good coach-athlete relationship.

What to do instead

Separate private from shared. Encourage athletes to keep private reflections that are theirs alone, and to share a smaller set of things with you on purpose. That might be their intention for the week, their session effort rating, and a short note on what they want feedback on. In a competition week that might also be how they slept the night before and what they want to focus on in warm-ups. What athletes should write in a journal is a useful starting point to give them.

Let athletes choose what to share. When sharing is a choice, what you see is more likely to be genuine. Some athletes will share a lot. Others will share very little at first and more as trust grows. Both are fine.

Be clear about what you'll do with it. Tell athletes up front: "I'll read what you share, and I'll use it to adjust training and start conversations. I won't use it against you in selection decisions." Then keep that promise.

Respond to what they share. If an athlete shares that their sleep has been off all week and nothing changes, they'll stop sharing. A short acknowledgement or a two-minute conversation shows it mattered.

Respond to patterns, not single entries. This is the same principle behind monitoring athlete wellness without expensive tech. One frustrated reflection after a rough session or a lost match is normal. A consistent shift over weeks is worth a conversation.

If something an athlete shares suggests they're struggling beyond normal training stress, take it seriously and help connect them with appropriate support.

Give athletes a journal they control

Sherpa is a free athlete journal where athletes set intentions, log reflections, and track how they feel. We're also building tools for coaches. In the meantime, your athletes can start on the App Store.

Give your athletes a reflection habit

A focus before practice and a two-minute reflection after, on their own phone. Free, on iOS.

Free on iPhone and iPad.

More from the blog

Start Journaling Free